Dear Wendy
Dear Wendy

“My Boyfriend Lies About Past Relationships”

pinocchio

Two years ago I began dating a man with whom I get on extremely well. We took the relationship slowly even though we really liked each other from the start. He has a grown child from a relationship, and I have two teenagers still at home. We introduced each other to our children after six months of dating and everyone gets along well, so there are no conflicts there.

At the beginning of our relationship we shared our dating histories. He is 55 and I am 48. His background of never being married was a little worrisome to me because I wondered if he was a commitment-phobic person. He has been completely attentive and committed to me, so that doesn’t seem to be his problem. What is disturbing to me is that over the past few years I have learned that he lied to me about his dating history. He told me initially that he had never dated anyone beyond six months, but then I learned that he had dated one woman for ten years and another for two. He told me about a month-long trip to China that he took with a group and his daughter, when his daughter was a teenager. Later I learned that he took a girlfriend with them, too. That was after he had told me months before that it was just he and his daughter on the trip.

We never fight, but, on the two occasions when I confronted him about the lies, he got angry with me and stormed out of my house. Then he texted me from his car, stating that he was done with me. Later he returned to tell me he was sorry for behaving very immaturely and that he had over-reacted.

He is still friendly with his daughter’s mother, and each year his family gathers for Christmas and she is invited. I was invited the first year we dated, and the ex attended. It was uncomfortable for me because his daughter is now 26 and her mother has been remarried for 15 years!! When I told him it was uncomfortable for me, he said that he understood and that she (the ex) should not be included, but that it has just become tradition. The following year, he invited me and told me that the ex was coming. I said that I was uncomfortable since I believe that, by this point in our relationship, she should not be included in such intimate family gatherings. (The gathering takes place at his house). I did not give him an ultimatum but said that I just did not feel comfortable with it and elected not to attend. He said “ok.” After a few days, he decided to dis-invite her, but he used a lame excuse that had nothing to do with the real reason. Why could he not just tell her that it is no longer appropriate for her to be included – she is long married to someone else and I am his serious girlfriend? Her husband never comes to these things, and I believe he probably is uncomfortable about them, too.

I feel very torn. On one hand, this man is very attentive, loving, and committed to me. We get along beautifully. On the other hand, I feel like I am one in a long, long, LONG string of girlfriends. He assures me that I am “the one” and he believes we could be married “one day.” I wonder if I am being strung along and will fall to the wayside like 50+ women before me, or if he is sincere about marrying me.

Thoughts? — One in a Long String of Girlfriends

I feel very torn, too. On one hand, I’m baffled about why your 55-year-old boyfriend would lie and tell you he’d never had a relationship longer than six months when, in fact, he’d had a couple long-term relationships. On the other hand, I’m baffled about why you are totally flipping the eff out over the fact that at 55 he’s had two serious relationships and that he took a girlfriend on vacation with him once. How does that equate to you being just one more woman in a “long, long, LONG string of girlfriends” or you “being strung along [to] fall to the wayside like 50+ women before” you? That’s just kind of crazy. It’s AT LEAST as crazy as lying about the length of previous relationships, if not more so.

You say your boyfriend is “very attentive, loving, and committed to you”? Then chill out. You’re going to lose this guy if you continue behaving like a jealous teenage girl. So, he’s had a couple of girlfriends before you. HE’S fifty-fucking-five years-old. Yes, it’s bizarre that he lied about it, but maybe he had a sneaking suspicion you’d freak out about thinking of him with another woman besides you. After all, look at how you’re behaving about his maintaining a civil relationship with his ex-girlfriend. They have a daughter together. How nice for her that, once a year, her parents can put aside whatever differences they had in their relationship and celebrate the holidays with her, together, under one roof, along with other family and friends. All kids of divorce/separated parents, grown or not, should be so lucky. This is a lovely gift that they’ve been able to give their daughter, and you are out of line to try to sabotage it. As you said, the ex-wife has been married for 15 years. Your boyfriend invites her to his Christmas gathering for his daughter’s benefit. It’s one occasion a year the daughter gets to have her whole family together, and why should she have to give that up because her father’s 48-year-old girlfriend can’t handle the idea of her boyfriend having previous relationships?

I think all of this boils down to the final few words of your letter: “(I wonder if) he is sincere about marrying me.” You feel uncertain or insecure about your future together, and you’re projecting that insecurity onto all these petty things. This isn’t really about your boyfriend remaining civil with an ex or withholding the fact that he took a former girlfriend on vacation with him to China over a decade ago. This is about whether or not there’s a future for the two of you. You need to feel like you’re on the same page. Causing a big fuss over whom your boyfriend invites to his family Christmas party this year isn’t going to get you the clarity you need. Obsessing over his past relationships isn’t going to get you the clarity you need. The only thing that will give you the clarity you desire about the state of your union, present and future, is to sit down and talk about it with your boyfriend. So do that. Ask him if he’s sincere about marrying you and, if so, when. Ask him why he’s lied to you about previous relationships. Ask him why he feels he can’t be honest and what YOU can do to make him feel more comfortable opening up to you.

***************

Follow along on Facebook, and Instagram.

If you have a relationship/dating question I can help answer, you can send me your letters at wendy@dearwendy.com.

40 comments… add one
  • Lianne

    Lianne October 22, 2014, 8:13 am

    My guess, based on the little I can glean from your letter, is that you are a jealous person by nature, which is lending to the insecurity you’re feeling about your relationship. As a 35 year old woman with divorced parents, I would LOVE it if my parents were civil enough to attend a holiday event together so that I didn’t have to run around to 4 different places on Christmas eve and day (my fiance is also from a divorced family, so yay for us). As Wendy says, chill out! His ex is remarried and has been for 15 years. If anything, you should be cultivating a relationship with her because, despite his daughter’s age, if you do marry him, she will be part of your life for the long haul.

    Reply Link
  • avatar

    RedroverRedrover October 22, 2014, 8:31 am

    Whatever you do about him, tell him right now to reinvite his ex to Christmas so she can make plans. How are you threatened by someone who’s been an ex for so long, and who’s happily remarried? Don’t ruin Christmas for his daughter with your petty jealousy. Jeez.

    Reply Link
    • FireStar

      FireStar October 22, 2014, 8:50 am

      Unbelievable. She says the new husband probably feels uncomfortable too so he stays away. Why not take a page out of his book? He doesn’t try to destroy a family tradition even though he is married to the woman going to her ex-boyfriend’s house…yet the new girl friend does? If you are so uncomfortable then go do something else. Your behaviour is just selfish… and short-sighted.
      And I hate to break it to you but you had no real problems – lying about a girlfriend coming on a trip years before he even knew you? who cares? But congratulations because if it’s problems you wanted you have some now because there is no way the daughter is liking the likes of you after you excluded her mother from the family tradition that has gone on happily this whole time…so good luck trying to convince her dad to marry you “one day”.

      Reply Link
      • FireStar

        FireStar October 22, 2014, 8:56 am

        To clarify – not giving an ultimatum but guilting someone into what you want them to do is not the same as ‘this is your tradition – not for me – you have fun and I’ll see you later” which is what should happen.

        Link
      • something random

        something random October 22, 2014, 9:51 am

        Good call. Stating that she did not give an ultimatum diverted me from this when I first read it.

        Link
  • Raccoon eyes

    Raccoon eyes October 22, 2014, 8:36 am

    Wendy is right (per usual) that the issue is really your insecurity about your future with your boyfriend. Which is fed by your insecurity about his past. Realistically, HE HAS A PAST. It would be impossible for him to be the “attentive, loving, and committed” boyfriend you say he is if he had NO relationship experience. Is it f*cking weird he lies to you about his past relationships? Totally. Can you deal with that?
    *
    Also, if on two separate occasions he stormed out of your house after being confronted with his conflicting stories, I dont really think this qualifies as “[w]e never fight.” I’m just sayin.’

    Reply Link
    • avatar

      ktfran October 22, 2014, 9:10 am

      So yeah, LW, the way you wrote this letter, it seems you’re focusing on the fact that he had past relationships. Not that he lied to you about them. I would be concerned with the later, not the former. Why did he lie? Is it because he rightfully figured out you are jealous or insecure? Or is he just a tall tale teller? Maybe it’s a little bit of both. I think you need to have a calm, rational discussion and figure that out before you proceed with the relationship.
      .
      Also, wtf. The guy is damned if he does and damned if he doesn’t. You were concerned about a 55 year old never being married. Then you were concerned that he had a couple long-term girlfriends? The 10-year relationship was probably pretty darn close to a marriage, just without the signed papers. I mean, he CAN’T win with you.
      .
      My final thought, I’m so tired of hearing about people and their insecurities with past relationships. Especially when there are children. I think it speaks VOLUMES about the character of the people involved if they’re able to remain civil. Grow the eff up already.

      Reply Link
      • avatar

        ktfran October 22, 2014, 9:10 am

        That wasn’t meat to be a reply. Sorry. It was meant to stand on its own.

        Link
      • avatar

        catz47 October 22, 2014, 9:17 am

        I totally agree that this guy probably had the sense that LW would be jealous and insecure, and tried to hide/downplay his past so as to keep everything calm and drama free, and to keep from inciting LW’s jealous wrath. Was it the right move on his part? No. Buuuut here we are. LW, chill out. Seriously.

        Link
      • FireStar

        FireStar October 22, 2014, 10:08 am

        It’s true – he can’t win. She had a better concern when she thought the 55 year old’s longest relationship was 10 months…finding out about the long term girlfriends should have been comforting. Honestly, this is how girls act at 15. That is the age they don’t want their first boyfriends to have had a past relationships…hard to believe the LW is 48 and a mother of two.

        Link
  • something random

    something random October 22, 2014, 8:46 am

    I know letter writer is going to take a lot of crap for the christmas thing. And it’s good that she didn’t demand boyfriend stop the invites but rather made her feelings clear and decided not to attend. But I have to agree with Wendy that most people wouldn’t have such a strong reaction to the “appropriateness” of the situation. There is objectively nothing inappropriate about it. The insecurity really is puzzling.

    One thing I’m not clear on is if he just represented himself as a blank slate when you guys were first getting to know each other or if he has continued to make little lies throughout the relationship. Letter writer says she “found out” about a ten year relationship and a girlfriend who went to China. Does this mean the boyfriend told her later on down the line? Or that maybe she picked it up from obvious reminders such as photographs and chit chat with the kids? If this is the case, it would seem he just didn’t feel comfortable getting into his dating history early on. Maybe he never wants to get into it. How much does it really matter?

    I do think his reaction to the “confrontation” is a major red flag, though. Maybe he has some skeletons and he’s willing to gaslight about them. Clearly the letter writer believes being able to speak openly and honestly about the first four decades of their lives is important. She’s of the history repeats itself camp. I think Wendy was spot as usual in her advice. Hopefully the letter writer will listen.

    Reply Link
    • something random

      something random October 22, 2014, 9:45 am

      “Why could he not just tell her that it is no longer appropriate for her to be included – she is long married to someone else and I am his serious girlfriend?”

      Letter writer, this statement is also a red flag but for you boyfriend. You clearly didn’t hear or respect HIS feelings on this issue any more than he heard yours. The difference is yours was based on discomfort with his innocuous holiday traditions with loved ones. While it was fine to make your feelings clear and decide not to attend, it was also unflattering jealous and unsupportive. It would have been healthier if your boyfriend had chosen to continue is tradition without you and left you to examine your discomfort. Unfortunately, he chose to accommodate you and this somehow made you feel validated in disapproving of a charming family tradition. It’s okay to feel uncomfortable and take time to examine it. Your quote suggests you were WAY over invested in him completely severing his relationship with his child’s mom whom he has known for at least damn near thirty years. This is a controlling intention and you should be aware others would perceive it as a Major red flag.

      Just to clarify I’m not giving you a pass.

      Reply Link
      • Raccoon eyes

        Raccoon eyes October 22, 2014, 10:07 am

        This! For the life of me, I cannot stand when someone gets into a relationship with a person who is a parent, and thinks that all previous arrangements/boundaries must immediately be ceased or changed solely for the comfort of the new person. When kids are involved- grown or still young- traditions in the family unit are important, and it is not the “right” of the new person to decide what exactly the arrangements/boundaries are to be or their appropriateness. (With a caveat, I suppose- if parents are like spoon-feeding each other and absolutely ignoring new person or something.)
        *
        Also, unless you know for sure, LW, mom’s husband could be staying away from the family Christmas for innumerable reasons, from allowing that family to have the tradition to having a job where he values time at home alone to decompress (or a Chandler Bing-style aversion to a usually beloved holiday and its traditions). Who knows why he stays away? Just because him being uncomfortable with the tradition like you are fits better into your side of the argument doesnt mean that is the reason that he does not attend.

        Link
      • avatar

        RedroverRedrover October 22, 2014, 12:28 pm

        Maybe the husband has kids with another woman too, and he goes to his ex’s house to be with his kids? Like a mature adult?

        Link
      • Raccoon eyes

        Raccoon eyes October 22, 2014, 2:26 pm

        HAHA, yes!

        Link
  • avatar

    csp October 22, 2014, 8:56 am

    OMG LW, chill out. The Christmas thing is WONDERFUL! Honestly, the daughter is so lucky and the ex is not looking to get back together. Someday, there could be grandkids and there will be holidays, birthdays, religious milestones. For you to come in and ask for this to end is so cruel. The idea that a couple can put the past behind them and say, “We don’t love each other anymore but we both love our daughter” is so great to show that a family might not be together but they still get along. I have a friend who had a kid with a guy and they broke up before the baby was born. Every year, they take a family picture on their son’s birthday with just Mom, Dad, and him. They have since moved on to other relationships and have other kids but they both show that he is loved by both of them separate from the two new family units. It is the sweetest, most mature thing to do. Please, please tell your boyfriend that you made a mistake and don’t ruin Christmas.

    Reply Link
    • Raccoon eyes

      Raccoon eyes October 22, 2014, 9:57 am

      Your friend’s tradition is amazing. What a great idea

      Reply Link
  • avatar

    Kate October 22, 2014, 9:13 am

    First, just to get it out of the way, is your boyfriend a pathological liar? I’ve known a few.

    If not, then I have a hunch that, early on in the relationship, you freaked out about something he said to you, and since then he’s been cautious about how much information he gives you. I did something similar early on with my husband when he told me he used to be a “bad boy.” If you’re not open to hearing certain things and have shown that you’ll flip out, a guy is probably going to avoid telling you the whole truth. Lying about having a 10year relationship IS bizarre, but think back… Might you have given him a reason to want to cover things up?

    The trip thing – that’s not a big deal in my book. When you’re getting to know someone, I think it’s pretty normal to talk about vacations and such and gloss over who exactly was with you on the trip. You find out later it was the girlfriend, but who cares? Of course it was.

    Reply Link
    • avatar

      Kate October 22, 2014, 11:37 am

      Ok, now that I read your update, it’s not far off from what I thought. He didn’t want to be perceived as a player (maybe because some woman before you had freaked out), so he edited his history. You have to understand that a guy who does this is a guy who will try to cover things up to avoid being seen in a negative light or being embarrassed. That’s a fact. And you HAVE caught him in multiple lies. It seems like a lot of lies and just overall kind of bizarre and convoluted. If he’s really devoted to you and once in a while lies about something stupid but comes clean when you call him out, and then over time you aren’t catching him in lies anymore because he’s stopped lying about stupid shit, then you can live with that, right? But if you never know if what he’s telling you is true or not, and he’s lying about stuff that matters and has important implications, maybe you can’t live with it.

      I’m also concerned about his seeming need to find the “perfect” partner and that he says he wants to marry you but won’t commit to a timeframe. Those are not great signs.

      Reply Link
  • bagge72

    bagge72 October 22, 2014, 9:40 am

    I had some sympathy for you at first, until you made him disinvite his daughter’s mother to Christmas, and ruining the one normal tradition she has with her family. Your jealousy is just ruining everything.

    Reply Link
    • bagge72

      bagge72 October 22, 2014, 9:43 am

      I honestly can’t think of a reason why a 48 year old women with two teenagers from a previous relationship could not understand how important that must be to the daughter, and her boyfriend in that situation.

      Reply Link
      • FireStar

        FireStar October 22, 2014, 10:03 am

        EXACTLY.

        Link
  • fast eddie

    fast eddie October 22, 2014, 9:12 am

    The LW’s jealousy was probably obvious to this guy early on and being 55 his opportunities for sex and companionship love were sparse. Therefor he withheld his history out of fear. Best outcome is to cut him loose to find someone that isn’t a nut case. They don’t trust each other and never will.

    Reply Link
    • fast eddie

      fast eddie October 22, 2014, 9:26 am

      Most people put their past behind them, this guy put his into another galaxy but the debris (kids) from the blast off lingers for decades. All his screws need to be tightened or replaced.

      Reply Link
  • avatar

    jlyfsh October 22, 2014, 10:17 am

    Your letter leaves me wondering what kind of relationship you have with your ex and his family. Hopefully you can find a way to step back from this and realize there is nothing wrong with being able to co-parent in a civil way that involves including that co-parent in holiday celebrations. Even when the child is grown, it’s nice to be able to celebrate together. Family doesn’t stop being important because you turn 18.

    Obviously though your issue is much bigger than your boyfriend being a successful co-parent. You don’t trust him because he lied about his past. So like Wendy said talk to your boyfriend and discuss the parts of your relationship that you are uncomfortable with. But, please leave his daughter and the family he has built for her, which I’m sure he would hope would also be able to include you, out of those discussions. And maybe instead talk about how the family you will build together that includes his daughter and your’s will look like.

    Reply Link
  • Kate B.

    Kate B. October 22, 2014, 10:35 am

    Without having read all the comments, I have to say I am not a fan of men who lie. I would end this relationship simply on that basis. No matter what he reason might be, he chose to lie. However, having said that, I agree with Wendy that you are way overreacting about the past girlfriends. (And I say this as a person who is prone to jealousy.) Frankly, it would be more worrisome to me if a 55-year old man DIDN’T have past girlfriends. (Or boyfriends, for that matter.) As for his daughter’s mother, she’s his daughter’s mother, and you cannot expect her to be excluded from family events. This relationship does not sound healthy on either end. I would MOA.

    Reply Link
  • Addie Pray

    Addie Pray October 22, 2014, 11:04 am

    It’s funny, after reading LW’s first couple of paragraphs about how the 55 year old boyfriend lied about past relationships, I figured the concern would be “what else is he lying about? Can I trust him?” or something along those lines, but the concern was “I feel like I am one in a long, long, LONG string of girlfriends … and will fall to the wayside like 50+ women before me.” That’s a weird leap. Is that really the concern? Not that he LIED to your face about something so… so simply as whether he had prior relationships or not? I would be really upset to know he just lied to my face. And if he lied because he felt that I couldn’t handle knowing he had prior relationships, then I’d also feel insulted, like he doesn’t think I’m mature enough to handle the truth. So, just focusing on that issue, I’d talk to him. It sounds like you have though, and he gets mad. So I’m curious: what exactly have you talked to him about? If it’s “Does this mean you’re just using me?” then yeah I’d be pissed to. You gotta focus on the lie aspect of it and how it kills your trust. … I dunno, I am not good at relationships, but that to me seems like the big issue.
    *
    As for the holiday gatherings with his daughter’s mother, I think you’re being unreasonable. She’s been remarried for 15 years now so what’s the big deal? If it makes you so uncomfortable, why don’t you stay home like the ex’s husband does? It’s their gathering with their daughter, let them have that gathering together – it’s for the daughter. You can celebrate with your boyfriend and his kids separately, no? Seems like a no brainer – and very remote from the lying issue.

    Reply Link
  • Dear Wendy

    Dear Wendy October 22, 2014, 11:12 am

    From the LW:

    Hi Wendy,

    I love your response and I read the response of others. I was unable to post to the others so maybe this response will make its way to the respondents.

    Sadly, I did not make myself clear about the Christmas event. I love that the ex and my boyfriend have a good relationship. In fact, I invited her to his birthday party that I had for him at my home. I was upset because if given the choice between me and her he chose her and said that to me. I don’t feel there should be a choice and, if so, at what point do I become the first choice?

    As for lying to me about his past, he flat out lied to me and there should have been no reason. On our second date, he asked me about my dating history and I gave him an overview. I asked him about his. There was no judgement or further discussion after he shared with me, what turned out to be a pack of lies. As we moved through the relationship, I found that he had lied about his history. On our first date, he told me he was divorced, but I later learned he had never been married. He told me originally that he only dated his daughter’s mother for five months. In reality they “sorta kinda lived together” for “six or so years.” That is a BIG difference. He told me he and his daughter took the trip to China and no one else was with him, but I later learned about a girlfriend of two years having gone with them. I am not jealous, at all, and I expect a man of 55, never been married, to have had relationships. I question why he lied to me. I have caught him in so many lies about other women that it does give me pause. Why the lies?

    I took your advice and asked him straight away. He told me that he lied because he was embarrassed by his “sketchy” dating past, primarily that he did not want me to think he was a player. Apparently, it has caused problems for him in the past, so he chose to lie to me based on that and nothing I have ever said. I told him that it is the lies that bother me and not his past. Since he lied, and I did not know why, it made me feel as though he was playing me. He said he wants to marry me, but he was no committal as to when.

    Wendy, my boyfriend has been searching for the perfect mate his whole life, but never found the perfect one because no one is perfect. Each woman he has been serious with has had potential for a LTR, but when push came to shove, his need for solitude and independence were so strong that he was able to find fault with the woman and he bailed. So this kind of past makes me feel very nervous about a future with him. At what point am I no longer “perfect?”

    Reply Link
    • Addie Pray

      Addie Pray October 22, 2014, 11:39 am

      Oy, this is a mess. The lies are terrible, yes. What’s up with that? That’s sketchy. But you’re all ove board
      *
      Why did you give him the “choice between me and her” – there is no choice, you feel that there shouldn’t be a choice, but you’re asking him to make a choice? What are you 9? He’s not with her, he’s with you.
      *
      I’m not sure what advice you’re seeking. The lies seem shady. Your issue with the ex being invited to events with the daughter seems shady. That his past makes you feel very nervous about a future with the boyfriend seems… misplaced. I’d think the lies would do it but ok.
      *
      What was the question?
      *
      I have a man coming to visit me in ONE WEEK. A MAN. A SINGLE MAN. WHO IS CUTE. AND NICE. AND HE IS COMING TO SEE MEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE. (Sorry, I didn’t know where to put that.)

      Reply Link
      • Addie Pray

        Addie Pray October 22, 2014, 11:42 am

        ^ So wish me luck. I figure it’s going to be fantastic or terrible but probably nothing in-between but I’m taking a chance!
        *
        Ok, back to LW.

        Link
      • avatar

        jlyfsh October 22, 2014, 11:52 am

        Yeah I’m very confused as to what the LW wants to get an answer about as well. Is he going to leave her because he’s commitment phobic, maybe. But, I don’t think we can answer that because we can’t see the future. I also wonder what problems having a full dating life caused, unless he was not truthful in those relationships either?
        .
        And I agree with the choosing one over another. Why make him choose? It seems like another power play trying to feel confident in the relationship. If he chooses me he must be more serious than I think.
        .
        I would ask myself if I was really happy in this relationship and if I was actually getting out of it what I wanted. If not why stay? Why wait to see if he’s going to leave you if you’re not happy?
        .
        Go AP! Good luck! 🙂

        Link
      • avatar

        ktfran October 22, 2014, 12:08 pm

        I agree with both of you. And rewording the Christmas thing doesn’t make you sound any better LW. At all.
        .
        However, I do think there are some red flags with this dude. The outright lying is troublesome. IDK, I think I would cut my losses and MOA.

        Link
      • avatar

        jlyfsh October 22, 2014, 12:32 pm

        yeah i think that’s why she needs to step back and really think about if she’s happy here. it doesn’t sound like she is when she takes in to consideration his lying, so why stay in this relationship? It seems like she wants things to be perfect and work out even though they aren’t. Which I think a lot of people can relate too, but wanting something bad isn’t enough.

        Link
      • avatar

        RedroverRedrover October 22, 2014, 12:38 pm

        I can kinda see the Christmas thing if she feels that the ex really is more important than her. But I think what she’s missing is that it’s not the ex who’s more important, it’s the daughter. The ex is presumably only invited for the daughter’s sake. And if he’s making the choice that his daughter is more important than the LW, then he’s doing the right thing IMO.

        Although the fact that this is even an issue should be a red flag (for him). She should have either sucked it up and been uncomfortable, or she should have said she won’t go, but in a way where she reassured him that she thinks he should continue the tradition and keep the ex there. This wasn’t one she should have been trying to “win”. The “win” is for the daughter to be happy and for her relationship with her parents to continue to be good. You don’t try to put yourself ahead of someone’s kids.

        Link
      • avatar

        RedroverRedrover October 22, 2014, 12:39 pm

        And I would MOA too. It doesn’t seem like he’s all that interested in the kind of commitment the LW is asking for, plus the lying is an issue. Maybe he only lied about this and everything else is fine, but who knows?

        Link
      • bagge72

        bagge72 October 22, 2014, 1:11 pm

        I want to know what part is so uncomfortable at these Christmas parties! Are the BF, and his ex like really touchy feel, and all over each other, or are they just acting like a family, and having fun on a holiday with each other? I think this probably does come down to the relationship she does have with her kids father. She must think that since they are ex’s they shouldn’t be friends, because that is what she is used too.

        Link
      • avatar

        RedroverRedrover October 22, 2014, 1:21 pm

        Yeah, that confused me too. Also, why did she invite the ex to the bf’s birthday party at her home, but then complain about her being around on Christmas? It just doesn’t seem to make sense. Maybe the ex didn’t come to the bday party, and the LW knew she wouldn’t, so she felt it was ok to invite her and look good even though she didn’t really want her there?

        I don’t know, this update just brings up more questions than answers. I don’t think the LW is going to get what she wants from us. I can’t see a way to fix whatever’s going on here, and it’s probably best if she moves on.

        Link
      • FireStar

        FireStar October 22, 2014, 2:24 pm

        I want to know too. Because if the ex is cool enough to invite for the birthday party then what is so special at Christmas? They hang out under the mistletoe? If the boyfriend left the LW in the dark to go screw in a light bulb at his daughter’s mother’s house I could see what the issue could be. That is a her vs. me kind of thing. But this I just don’t see that way at all.

        Link
    • bagge72

      bagge72 October 22, 2014, 1:06 pm

      Unfortunately the only thing this follow-up did for me, was make me think the Christmas thing is even worse. You made him choose between you and his daughter’s mother…over a Christmas Party! You never should have put him in that situation, and clearly you don’t love his relationship they have together. And in the end he did choose you because he went and disinvited her, because of how “uncomfortable” you were with this women attending a holiday party because the daughter is now a grown women and shouldn’t need her parents to be cordial to each other anymore apparently.
      The rest of the follow up really just gives us the same info really. Yeah his lying sucks, and very weird that he thinks long term relationships are part of a sketchy past. It seems you are both hung up on some things that really need to be talked about in more depth than just his lying.

      Reply Link
  • avatar

    kakattack October 25, 2014, 12:23 pm

    LW, you really need to get over your jealousy, especially with the ex attending holiday functions. Both sets of my grandparents are divorced and remarried, and we do holidays with everyone and have for as long as I can remember. (So Thanksgiving/Christmas is Grandpa/new wife, Grandma/boyfriend, my parents, my aunts and uncles, cousins, etc.) And my grandparents divorced in the 1970s!
    It’s always been really nice to have 1 holiday function instead of 2, and it’s also nice to see everyone getting along cordially. I think it taught me from a young age that you can be friendly with exes, especially if you share children/grandchildren.
    And how do you know the ex-girlfriend’s husband stays away because he was uncomfortable? Did you ask him? Are you a mind-reader?

    Reply Link

Leave a Comment