Dear Wendy
Dear Wendy

Asking for a diamond

Home Forums Get Advice, Give Advice Asking for a diamond

Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 104 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #670366 Reply
    TheHizzy
    Guest

    So, I have some time before I have to ask but I wanted some advice on how to ask my mom.

    My boyfriend and I are in a great relationship and we are discussing marriage. We have talked about the type of engagement ring I would want and even went looking over the weekend to get an idea. I really don’t want a brand new ring, but I don’t have a family heirloom neither does he.

    About 10 years ago my dad got my mom a new band for her wedding ring finger and she hasn’t ever worn her actual wedding/engagement set for as long as I remember. I would like to keep the diamond in the family. I have never broached the topic with my mom of asking for her diamond to re-set into a new setting.

    How have people in the past asked their family for a family ring, or diamond. And how do you approach it as “I want to re-set the diamond.” I want to come across as compassionate as asking her to part with her engagement ring, should I offer to pay for it, or replace the diamond? Should I have this conversation with my mom without my boyfriend? Should I just start dropping a hint or two in a few months of “I’d love to keep that in the family”? Just looking for guidance.

    #670368 Reply
    TheHizzy
    Guest

    I should also mention I have never talked about this EVER in the past with my mom so I think it would be a total shock to her.

    #670371 Reply
    Skyblossom
    Participant

    Unless your mom has at some point indicated that she would like you to have her engagement ring as your own you don’t ask for it. It isn’t yours and it is both presumptuous and rude to think of it as yours or to ask for it. It belongs to your mom. Maybe she doesn’t wear it because she is afraid it will be lost. Whatever her reason it is her reason and her ring. If she offers it is a totally different situation but you shouldn’t ask.

    #670373 Reply
    RedRoverRedRover
    Guest

    I think it depends a lot on the personalities involved. If it were me and my mom, I’d probably ask why she never wore it. Maybe there’s a reason that would make it seem weird for you to wear it, I don’t know. But if not, then I’d probably say something like “what if *I* wore it?”. I’d also offer to pay, because I have siblings and it wouldn’t be right for me to get a diamond and they get nothing.

    #670378 Reply
    Essie
    Participant

    Hm. For myself, personally, I don’t think I could ask. It’s not like an heirloom ring, where one or both of the parties are dead. Your parents are both very much alive and married, and just because the ring isn’t on her hand doesn’t mean it doesn’t have great meaning to her. I mean, my mom doesn’t wear her ring anymore because she’s 83 and it doesn’t fit her arthritic hands, but I would never in a million years ask her to give it up.

    An engagement ring doesn’t have to be a diamond solitaire, if you’re not feeling that, and it doesn’t have to cost a fortune. Widen the search a little, and I’ll bet you can find something that suits you.

    #670380 Reply
    Kate
    Keymaster

    I’m with Skyblossom. I feel like a diamond needs to be offered, not asked for.

    #670383 Reply
    TheHizzy
    Guest

    Years ago I had asked her why she never wore it and she said it doesn’t fit anymore and didn’t want to get it resized. She opted to wear different rings until she got her diamond band from my dad.

    I’m going in knowing she has every right to say no. My goal is to turn her diamond into a family one. I am under NO assumption that it is MINE. I understand fully that it is hers and it would be a major thing for her to part with it.

    I was trying to view it as honoring her and my father and their marriage. She has already told me that I will be receiving her jewelry after she passes. I just would have figured she might like to see her diamond worn while she’s still around.

    #670385 Reply
    SpaceySteph
    Guest

    What makes you so sure there is no family heirloom? I mean obviously not like some big fancy diamond passed down from the Duchess of Somesuch, but what happened to your grandmothers’ rings? Or other family member’s rings?

    My sister’s husband proposed with my grandmother’s wedding band (she passed away years ago, my mom had it in a drawer). They weren’t wealthy so it wasn’t anything huge, just a gold band inset with small diamonds, and then they later had the diamonds reset. The husband is the one who called up my parents and said he knew my sister is sentimental and would like a family ring and my mom offered that ring.

    I think that’s the way to do it. Have your future fiance call them and ask about “family rings” vs that specific ring. Maybe they do have something from an older relative that they’d rather part with. Or maybe they don’t have a ring they want to give up at all. Some moms would probably be happy for their daughter to wear their engagement ring that they’ve stopped wearing, some wouldn’t. If they do offer it, he should make it clear that it may get altered or re-set.

    And if you don’t get a family ring, it’s still possible to buy a vintage ring from a jewelry shop. It might not have the family history, but it could still be a unique, older piece.

    #670386 Reply
    Kate
    Keymaster

    My concern would be she may feel guilted into saying yes, even though that’s not at all your intention, when she may actually prefer to hang onto it. She may be taken by surprise and not know how to say no.

    #670389 Reply
    TheHizzy
    Guest

    Thanks you @SpaceySteph

    I had asked when I was a kid, forever ago, about any family rings and as far as I know there aren’t any. So I would be starting one. I just wasn’t sure if it’d be better brought up by my boyfriend versus me. We live half way across the country and they haven’t had too much of a chance to fully build a relationship with him. He wants to ask both parents blessing before asking me to marry him. I wasn’t sure on timing…he wants to ask blessing in person so looks like we’ll be waiting a little longer.

    I had been looking at vintage stuff but would love to keep something in the family before we fully went down that route.

    #670391 Reply
    TheHizzy
    Guest

    @Kate

    I understand. Which is why I would want to start the conversation and let her think on it. If she would even say “Yes” right away I would ask her to spend a week to think on it at least. And she’d want to discuss it with my dad before she gave me an answer. She’s not one to answer so rash. And if she happened to, I’d put in a buffer because I don’t want regret from her side EVER.

    #670392 Reply
    Northern Star
    Guest

    I would not ask her. “Keeping a diamond in the family” usually means wearing it or offering it for a proposal after a beloved family member has passed on—not prying it away from your still-alive and still-married mom on your timetable.

    If you don’t like new rings for whatever reason, visit an antique store.

Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 104 total)
Reply To: Asking for a diamond
Your information: