“He Won’t Stop Talking to the Woman He Stopped Dating for Me”

I have been dating this guy for about six months and things are mostly good, but we fight about one thing: he won’t stop talking to the girl he was seeing before me. We met on a dating site and he was seeing her when we met; he said they were never exclusive or official in any way. He met her on a different dating site a few months prior to meeting me. They have no history of friendship. He still won’t stop communicating with her, saying they’re just friends. I don’t feel like he would cheat on me, but she gives me a terrible feeling. I reached out to her at one point, with his permission, to try get to know her. I was honest and told her I wasn’t sure how to deal with his being friends with an ex-lover. She became extremely defensive and told me my issues aren’t her problem.

Anytime she texts him or vice versa I have really bad anxiety, and this is starting to take a toll on my mental health (I have made an appointment with a therapist up help with the anxiety). He is not always honest with me about when they talk; he’s lied to my face and on occasion has admitted that he’s lied to avoid the same discussion over and over with no resolution.

This is clearly not in the best interest of my mental health; however, that does not seem to have any impact for him. He said he will not give up a friend because he would never ask me to do that. He’s divorced and said he won’t be told what to do anymore and my asking him to take my mental state into consideration is telling him what to do. This ex of his has tried to tell him that I clearly need mental help and that I’m not ready to be in a relationship. She tries to manipulate his opinion of me.

He tells me he loves me but he is unwilling to let go of an ex-lover. I would have way less issue if they had been friends previously or if it hadn’t ended between them because he met me and that wasn’t long ago. The anxiety of the fighting makes me sick and I’m not sure how to get him to pick me over her. I’m afraid if I gave him some type of ultimatum, I would lose him or he would just try to hide the fact from me that he still talks to her, but I don’t want to be that person. I want to know how to either be okay with her or how to get her out of the picture entirely.

He also won’t stop talking to the woman with whom he had an affair that ended his marriage. I actually have less of an issue with her because they were friends before the affair. I don’t like who she is and their history, but I’ve been dealing with her better than his most recent ex-lover.

Everyone I’ve spoken to about this has told me he’s being disrespectful and I deserve better. Advice from an unbiased third party would be much appreciated. — Suspicious of the Ex

He’s being disrespectful and you deserve better. But I have to say to you: take responsibility for your own behavior here. Why are you relying on this guy you’ve known for six months to take care of your mental health? Shouldn’t that be YOUR top priority? And if you’re dating someone who is causing this much mental anguish, you should MOA.

You say: “This is clearly not in the best interest of my mental health; however, that does not seem to have any impact for him.” Swap “me” for “him” and that’s how I’m reading your issue. Dating this guy is clearly having a big effect on your mental health. Is that having enough of an impact on you to leave? I sure hope so!

***************
If you have a relationship/dating question I can help answer, you can send me your letters at [email protected].

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *